WASHINGTON — About 250 rejected Chrysler Group dealerships in arbitration will get access to their Chrysler performance scores — and those of their competitors — under a decision by a federal bankruptcy judge this week.
U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Arthur Gonzalez in New York has unsealed each dealer’s spreadsheet of about 30 performance categories for use in arbitration, a copy of the judge’s decision shows.
The judge also held that each dealer can get copies of the performance charts of rivals to whom the dealer was compared when the dealer was terminated, the decision, made Tuesday, shows.
Dealerships can use these spreadsheets to evaluate the validity of Chrysler’s explanations of why they were shuttered, said dealer lawyer Leonard Bellavia, of Mineola, N.Y.
“We intend to show the many discrepancies between what Chrysler asserted in the bankruptcy hearings as criteria for rejection against what they now allege in the arbitrations, to show that Chrysler will argue whatever suits its purpose at that given time,” said Bellavia.
Chrysler has described each spreadsheet as “a historical track record” of sales and financial performance that incorporates comparisons between a dealership and competitors in his market area.








